You are viewing amandapillar

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Why do they have eyes?

I took Tom to see Thor: The Dark World today. Was lots of fun. I do love the Avenger series from Marvel. Great dialogue, awesome action scenes, fun special effects, and some nice sneaky plot lines.

But while I was happy to go along with the crazy science and magic of the Marvel world, the one thing that bothered me had Tom laughing.

In The Dark World there is a race of aliens called Dark Elves, who existed before light ever came to being in the universe. The light doesn't kill them or hurt them as far as I could tell, but it did piss them off. And so they wanted to get rid of all the light in the universe. And thus the movie's plot is born.

However, what I wanted to know was why the elves had eyes? In a dark universe, they would have evolved without the need for vision. They would have used echolocation or something cool like that. After all, primitive life is thought to have originally developed eyes to sense day from night; there would have been no need for that in a dark universe...

Then again, there would have been no plot if that was the case.

Also, I think Loki is way cooler than Thor. Just sayin'.



( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
5th Nov, 2013 12:52 (UTC)
What really counts as dark? It's strange to have this great big universe, and all the aliens see the same visible spectrum humans do.

Perils of working with mythology I guess.

Edited at 2013-11-05 12:53 (UTC)
8th Nov, 2013 05:03 (UTC)
Well, they mean an absence of light. And we can measure the electromagnetic spectrum...
6th Nov, 2013 21:45 (UTC)
Lol. We haven't seen it yet, but when I read this to Lewis his comment was "Maybe their eyes to echolocation!"

But as for elves existing before light... before light means before stars. HOW do they get the energy to live at all?
6th Nov, 2013 21:51 (UTC)
And then I started ranting to L about how Elves evolving in the cosmological dark ages doesn't even make sense because at that point the universe was composed entirely of hydrogen with only a little bit of helium and lithium thrown in and NOTHING ELSE AT ALL and even if you could form "planets" out of just hydrogen, there's no way you could form life because hydrogen really isn't the kind of element you can form anything larger than a hydrogen molecule (H2) out of. LET ALONE DARK ELVES.
8th Nov, 2013 05:05 (UTC)
Yeah, hehehe. The problem when you start looking a problem that wasn't really thought out beyond 'just cos'. And I mean, the Dark Elves looked carbon based.

But it's still a fun movie!
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )



Latest Month

November 2014

Book News


Graced, Amanda Pillar's first novel, will be out in 2015! More details to come.


Bloodlines will be out in 2015! Blood will tell... blood holds memory... blood is sacrifice... blood is thicker than water... blood is life.


Bloodstones, edited by Amanda Pillar, features 17 tales of urban fantasy set in the contemporary world. It is the first volume of an annual dark fantasy series.



Damnation and Dames, edited by Liz Grzyb and Amanda Pillar, will feature 16 tales of paranormal noir.

Ready for an adventure? Then put your coat on and step into the world of noir...



Ishtar. Powerful, sexy, and very, very deadly. And due out in November 2011! This outstanding novella collection contains gems from Deborah Biancotti, Kaaron Warren and Cat Sparks!



Each story in this collection has been inspired by a track from the album, Scenes from the Second Storey. Quirky, dark, insightful and sometimes downright disturbing, these tales reflect the emotions and images our authors experienced when they heard ‘their’ song from The God Machine's record.

Scenes from the Second Storey was published in September 2010. It features stories from Kaaron Warren, Robert Hood, Cat Sparks and Paul Haines among many other talented Australian authors.



Are you looking for a dark chocolate anthology full of tales about the Morrigan goddess?

The Phantom Queen Awakes is available now. It features stories from Elaine Cunningham, CE Murphy, Anya Bast and Katharine Kerr.



The award-winning Grants Pass is a post apocalyptic anthology, edited by Amanda Pillar and Jennifer Brozek, features stories by Cherie Priest, Ed Greenwood and Jay Lake among many other authors.


"Grants Pass is a remarkable, disturbing, and worthwhile read, and one that is likely to stay with the reader for some time to come."

- HorrorScope


Voices is available for sale now. You can purchase a copy online or at Fantastic Planet, Perth, and Pulp Fiction Books, Brisbane.

"Every story in Voices is of high quality, and the editors should be commended for their high standards. This is one of the best anthologies of dark fiction to have been released recently, and is highly recommended."

- HorrorScope

Powered by
Designed by Tiffany Chow